Blog Published

Blog_archdiocese-of-miami-lets-talk-blog-tarlton-do-all-lives-really-matter


We live in trying times when it comes to race relations. Though it seems as if, as a country, we always have. I hesitate to put words and thoughts in the mind of our Lord and Savior with respect to what he would say or think about these times. In reality, I feel that I do not need to. I believe Scripture is filled with Jesus’ words and actions that provide a glimpse of how he would feel about the issues of today.

We know that Jesus was Jewish, through and through. Scripture teaches us, sometimes in harsh terms (think Matthew 15:21-28), that Jesus’ initial message was strictly for the Jews. Yet, as his ministry progresses, we soon realize that Jesus’ message of love for his Father and love for neighbor included everyone — in particular all those who were looked down upon by the Jewish culture.

Why do you think Jesus used minorities and the economically impoverished as the protagonists in so many of his teachings? In Matthew 15:21-28, he uses a Canaanite woman. In Luke 10:25-37, the story of the Good Samaritan, and John 4:1-42, the woman at the well parable, he uses Samaritans. In Mark 21:41-44, Jesus uses a poor widow to make His point.

For Jesus, yes, “all lives” mattered. But at multiple times during his ministry, the focus would have been on “Samaritan lives matter” or “Gentile lives matter,” not at the expense of Jewish lives or even all other lives. During New Testament times, these groups were the minorities of the day. They were not seen as equals in the eyes of the Jews. Yet Jesus loved and healed them all, equally. After Jesus set the example for how to love (with all your heart, soul, and mind) and who to love (God the Father, and your neighbor), he commanded us in John 13:34 to “... love one another: just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another.”

It would have been difficult for Jesus to have said, “All lives matter” without tending to the needs of the Samaritan, of the despised tax collector, of the Roman centurion, of the poor widow and orphan, and of course of his Jewish brothers and sisters.

The “All Lives Matter” saying is often used to mute the mantra of “Black Lives Matter.” However, in comparison to the example set by Jesus, how can we say all lives matter when we have such a huge disparity in economic, educational, health care, housing, and nutritional resources in the Black, Native American, and Latino communities? Saying all lives matter, when we have such a disparity in access to these basic needs, is actually a distraction from Jesus’ teachings of inclusivity and participation in human society. These communities today are the Samaritans and Canaanites of Jesus’ time.

All lives can’t matter until we begin to love our disparate neighbors the way Jesus loved his.

Comments from readers

Carlos Rafael Bustamante - 01/17/2022 08:09 PM
Mr. Tarlton: Yes, your message is appropriate for the times we live. However, we, Americans should look beyond our pass, we can't change history, we can't use the excuse of our ancestors hold as slaves in order to request special treatment now. All cultures had experienced hard times under someone's oppression. Black live matters as same as anyone else' live. We have to look forward into a justice life for all. As long as we are divided, we won't be practicing the gospel of Christ. Love for all.
Deacon Vince and Teresa Eberling - 01/17/2022 01:53 PM
Your article resonated with me. In Ministry to Men, I see great untapped possibilities to address racism in our Church. There are others such as Deacon Harold Burke-Sivers, Deacon Larry Onley, and Deacon Chip Jones, who feel the same. Please contact me at your convenience so we can discuss this further. Great and timely blog article.
Rafael María Calvo Forte - 01/17/2022 10:20 AM
Nuestra sociedad sufre con distintos modos de opresión a la vista de todos y, nos decimos libres… Sólo los que se atrevan a ser samaritanos, podrán ayudar a las víctimas, inclusive a riesgo de la propia vida. Duscierno a veces: esto que estoy viendo y viviendo es humano y, no me atrevo a ser samaritano por miedo o subliminales amenazas…
Valli Leone - 01/17/2022 10:14 AM
Thanks, dear Charles, for this timely and appropriate message! Your words and references to the Gospel of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ confirm what my heart knows is true. I am ready, willing and able to march, to demonstrate and to speak out with and for any particular group where injustice is being waged. You also reminded me of a book I read long ago entitled, “The Color of Water.” When a young child asked his mother what color Jesus was, that was her answer. Alleluia! Keep on writing, my dear brother, meaningful articles like this one. Jesus never fails! ✝️⚓️💜

Powered by Parish Mate | E-system

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply