Blog Published


A statement titled “The right not to have to migrate” was recently issued by the Vatican’s Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development. But what does the right not to migrate actually mean?

This basic principle of Catholic social teaching regarding migration sometimes causes confusion because it seems contradictory. Some would say: "Of course you have the right to remain in your home country."

But the decision to leave is not always a free or easy one because circumstances impinge on people's free will. Violence, conflict, endemic poverty and climate change influence people’s decisions to move from their homeland.

Consistent with Catholic teaching, the goal of the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development is to support improving conditions in countries so that its citizens don’t feel like there is a need to leave. This means promoting human rights, liberty, and security in these countries. There is often a conflict involving the right to life, liberty and security versus the right to the freedom of movement.

The Church's social teaching on migration, beginning with “Exsul Familia,” the apostolic constitution on migration by Pope Pius XII, makes it clear that the right to migrate is a basic human right.

This decision was reaffirmed by Pope John XXIII, Vatican II, and more recently by Pope Benedict XVI, who stated: “There is a need to reaffirm the right not to emigrate, that is to remain in one's homeland.”

St. John Paul II said: “It is a basic human right to live in one's own country. However, this right becomes effective only if the factors that urge people to emigrate are constantly kept under control.”

Pope Francis has spoken often about the right people have to raise and support their family in a safe environment, in their home country.

The social teaching of the Church is based on the principle of the dignity of each human person. Each individual has the right to remain in their homeland, but that right is conditioned by the ability to access other basic human rights. If these rights are not available, then the person is free to migrate in search of better living conditions, or more importantly, to escape death.

Once the Church's social teaching is understood, it cannot be claimed that it foments or encourages migration from one country to another. It is always better to improve the living conditions in each country, so that people do not need to migrate.

Migration for humans holds innate challenges, some of which can be very detrimental if they are not controlled in a proper manner. Displacement and separation from one's family, language, and culture always has deleterious effects.

It is the teaching and hope of the Church that people should flourish where they were born. Consequently, the Church’s work is to support acceptable living conditions in all countries, so that people do not have to exercise their right to emigrate.

For this reason, recent criticism of Catholic Charities organizations and other social groups who assist migrants, no matter what their legal status, need to be understood in the light of the constant and wise social teaching of the Church.

Comments from readers

Jose Manuel Lorenzo - 06/27/2023 11:53 AM
Jose Manuel Lorenzo - 06/26/2023 05:56 PM
DIOS CREO EL MUNDO PARA TODOS Y NO SOLO PARA UNOS CUANTOS PRIVILEGIADOS Y AFORTUNADOS. Todos tenemos la responsabilidad de ayudar a nuestros hermanos que sufren en cualquier parte del mundo que sea. Hace más de dos mil años en la unica ocasión que nuestro senor mostro cierta agresividad fue en Domingo de ramos cuando les dio la vuelta a las mesas de monedas y hecho a los negociantes del templo. En 2023 anos no hemos cambiado nada somos todos culpables de avaricias y de NO proveer para nuestros hermanos. Me siento muy avergonzado de ver que ni los politicos, gobiernos, empresas, e instituciones financieras siguen ciegas a las verdaderas prioridades y realidades de este mundo. Solo unas pocas instituciones religiosas sin medios económicos son las que ven y hoyen los gritos desesperados de nuestros hermanos que no tienen ni donde caerse muertos y se van a sus camas sin un plato de comida dia tras noche. Pero son ellos los que pasaran por la frontera celestial sin pasaporte porque sus visas fueron ya procesadas por Dios con sus sufrimientos. Shame on all of us. Amen. JML
Alain - 06/26/2023 03:28 PM
All creatures of God deserve our respect and charity but false charity is very dangerous. In the U.S we have rule of law our U.S constitution, there is a difference between illegal aliens and lawful migration. Any church or organization that wants to take care of these "migrants " without any government handouts and be held responsible for feeding, housing, medical on there dollar is welcomed. Real charity comes from our Lord filling our hearts with the holy ghost not governments colluding with questionable organizations.
Carlos Rafael Bustamante - 06/26/2023 12:04 PM
La Iglesia es muy clara en su posición del derecho a emigrar cuando "ciertas circunstancias" producen problemas familiares. El problema está en COMO emigrar. Primeramente el negocio de tráfico de personas dirigido por las mafias. Segundo, presentarse en la frontera a exigir "derecho" de entrada. Nadie tiene deredho de entrada. Para todo hay un proceso legal a seguir. Tampoco los emigrantes pueden exigir que les den casa, comida, dinero, seguro médico indefinido. Quien quiere venir que venga a trabajar y a producir, no a ser una carga para el país anfitrión. HAY UNA MAFIA MUY GRANDE DETRAS DE TODO ESTO. Lo peor, que los representantes no han querido hacer una ley de imigración JUSTA. Nadie tiene voluntad para solucionar el problema, hablar es bonito, pero tomar decisiones es lo dificil y que nadie quiere hacer.

Powered by Parish Mate | E-system

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply